I read the posts and this is what I think (sorry if I repeat what's been posted before, but this is my way of mind mapping):
1) Like Mimpimanis: I like the colour, reminds me of chocolate and coffee.It's not a standard colour for a forum, that's why I like it and it's not distracting.
I also like the simple lay out.
But if you want to target more visitors/ members, you could choose a more active colour and lay out.
2) Thinking of commercialising the forum?
Please limit (or avoid) moving ads, very annoying, distracting and they stimulate epileptic attacks
3) Comparing with other forums
posts are way too often off topic. It is not very "efficient" nor "effective" when you are looking for certain information and you have to read too many off topic texts first. The searcher can lose her/his interest and surf on.
At the same time,
off topic posts colour the forum in a friendly, cosy little community (not every off topic post btw, as you can read e.g. in this topic) This makes this forum also different from other forums I know (which are more to the point)
So I think there is a choice to make in this. Not necessairly one or the other, but probably a balanced combi of both, but it needs a consequent hand (shoops, is this English?)
4) Yes I agree,
it's tIme to reorganise the subforums ("Living on Bali" instead of "Bali expat forum" ) Maybe even start subsubforums for a faster search and a more organised look (E.g. "Costs of living" as a sub of "Living on Bali") Especially when the forum is getting bigger and bigger they will make it more functional.
Dividing in Blocks & Subs, to give you an idea:
Announcements
Rules
Announcements, tips etc
Bali General:
General subs ( money related things, post office...)
Culture
News
Nature
Food
Language
Travelling
To Bali (e.g. tickets)
On Bali
Taxi
Busses
Accommodations
Immigration/emigration:
Immigration Bali/Indonesia
Visa
Work & Living (sub: costs of living)
immigration to (back to England, US, Germany)
Visa England, US, Germany (e.g. for Indonesian partners)
Communication & Streaming Media
Telephone
Internet
Streaming vids
Music
Others
Off topic subs
Events/ get to gethers
To buy and sell (second hand books, water cooker)
Sponsored links
5) I like the
blogs the way they are (as a subforum) It feels as they are a part of the forum and is more tempting to read them than when linked to a different blogsite.
6)
A non- Bali sub. ? To talk about granny's pants, blisters, football and other *non-sense* subjects (sorry to football freaks :wink: haha..)
I hope you understand what I have been typing, I am a very tired non-native-speaker
Good luck with the transformation, Spicychicken!