by ronb on Thu Jan 10, 2008 8:41 am
Hi Balined,
My Aussie a/c is Commonwealth, and my Indonesian a/c is Commonwealth Indonesia. The fees I cop are:
1. Transfer from Aussie a/c to Indo a/c has a fee of A$22 regardless of amount transferred. If you transfer the max $5000 then this is an 0.44% charge
2. if I withdraw Rp from the Indo a/c using a Commonwealth ATM there is no fee. Trouble is there are only a small number of these ATMs in the south and none in the north.
3. if I withdraw Rp from a BNI ATM the fee is Rp2,500. The max you can withdraw in one go from an ATM with 50,000 notes is 1,500,000 so this fee is 0.17% - withdrawing 3,000,000 from an ATM with 100,000 notes makes the fee 0.085%. BNI is one member of some group that Commonwealth is also in and the fees are lower if you use an ATM of a group member
4. if I withdraw from a BCA ATM (BCA is not in the group) the fee is higher - I don't do this much but I think the fee was around Rp6,500 - so its not too much of a killer if you need to
I think you could use any Aussie bank (if they offer international transfers as an internet banking service) and do International transfers to any Indo bank - and the fee for transfer out of Aus would be similar. I have heard that some Indo banks charge a fee for receiving the money - but I have no direct experience. Also recent posts on this forum say that some Indo banks may "lose " the transfered money for some days and then when prodded "find" it again. In that sense the Commonwealth Indonesia is reliable and fast without added fees - but the scarcity of ATMs is a downside. Also BNI, BCA and others allow you pay things using ATM machines (like Lion Air tickets) while the Commonwealth is not part of this. However, the Commonwealth does offer Internet banking services on the Indo account so you can pay to other Indo bank accounts this way - I pay our Indovision and Internet this way - there is a fee of Rp5,000 per transfer.
Hope this helps